Supplier Directory Subscribe
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Home / Field vs. Shop: What’s the Best Welding Process for Structural Steel Fabrication?

Field vs. Shop: What’s the Best Welding Process for Structural Steel Fabrication?

Whether structural steel welding is taking place in an indoor shop setting or outdoors in the field is a factor that either introduces or eliminates a host of elements, including wind, the enemy of shielding gas and the welding processes that rely on it. Here are some insights to help you choose the right structural steel fabrication process for a field application or for shop welding.

Posted: July 14, 2017

Structural steel fabricators face challenges on every job, from making accurate bids to maintain their competitiveness to meeting project deadlines and code requirements, passing inspections and implementing effective operator training. Choosing the best welding process and filler metal for welding structural steel is key, regardless if the application is a bridge, building or other such project. (first view)
Structural steel fabricators face challenges on every job, from making accurate bids to maintain their competitiveness to meeting project deadlines and code requirements, passing inspections and implementing effective operator training. Choosing the best welding process and filler metal for welding structural steel is key, regardless if the application is a bridge, building or other such project. (second view)
Using metal-cored wire instead of flux-cored wire can eliminate non-value-added activities in the shop. Since metal-cored wire doesn’t generate slag, post-weld activities such as grinding or chipping aren’t necessary, saving labor, time and money.
Advertisement
Advertisement

Structural steel fabricators face challenges on every job, from making accurate bids to maintain their competitiveness to meeting project deadlines and code requirements, passing inspections and implementing effective operator training. Choosing the best welding process and filler metal for welding structural steel is key, regardless if the application is a bridge, building or other such project. It helps ensure that fabricators achieve the greatest efficiencies and best quality in their operations. First, consider whether the structural steel welding will take place in an indoor shop setting or outdoors in the field, as this factor alone either introduces or eliminates a host of elements, including wind, the enemy of shielding gas and the welding processes that rely on it.

Stick welding and self-shielded flux-cored arc welding (FCAW-S) processes are most commonly used for structural steel applications in the field, while gas-shielded flux-cored arc welding (FCAW-G) and submerged arc welding (SAW) are used for indoor structural steel welding. MIG welding with solid and metal-cored wires is used in the shop as well, but not nearly as widely as FCAW-G. Fabricators should weigh the pros/cons of these welding processes and select the option that is best suited for their application. For example, for field applications decide between the portability and simplicity of stick welding versus the productivity of FCAW-S. For shop welding, the flexibility of FCAW-G, the cleanliness of MIG (solid or metal-cored) or the productivity of SAW are all factors to consider.

FILLER METALS AND PROCESSES FOR FIELD APPLICATIONS
While operators often use stick welding for outdoor jobs, changing to FCAW-S can dramatically improve productivity. Stick welding is a familiar process that is more portable, which is why welding operators often prefer it, especially if the application requires them to move around a lot. But it is also a notoriously slow one, due to frequent stick electr

ode changeovers (electrodes are consumed approximately every 12 in and must be replaced). That’s why, when a field application has a large amount of welding in a single location, several large and/or multi-pass welds, it could be much more productive to convert to a FCAW-S wire.

At the end of the day, choosing the right process for a field application depends on how much time will be spent welding versus how much time is spent relocating. If the operator is mostly stationary during an outdoor application, FCAW-S should be considered to boost productivity. If not, it might be wisest to stay with the stick welding process. If a changing welding process is desired, the fabricator may need to re-qualify the welding procedures for the application. Although this takes both time and effort, it can be worthwhile given the long-term cost savings through productivity increases. In structural welding applications, it is common to use “pre-qualified” welding procedures that require much less testing, minimizing this potential hindrance.

In some cases, it may be most effective to qualify and use both stick welding and FCAW-S on the same job. The areas that require minimal welding can use stick welding to enjoy the portability advantages and leave the heavy welding areas for FCAW-S where the higher welding productivity process will shine. Other considerations include:

  • Hydrogen levels: Most American Welding Society (AWS; Miami, FL) 7018 stick electrodes, which are the most widely used, have low diffusible hydrogen levels (4 ml per 100 g or H4 is common). The FCAW-S wires are H8 (8 ml per 100 g) or higher; H4 is not available.
  • Power sources: FCAW-S should be used with a constant voltage (CV) power source. Depending on the classification of the wire, it may require DCEN or DCEP polarity. DCEN is more common but not used for all FCAW-S wires. In many cases, an operator may already have a multi-process machine capable of these settings. If not, a CV-capable power source needs to be purchased.
  • Training: FCAW-S wires have distinct characteristics and operating requirements depending on the AWS classification (type of wire), including specific voltage and stick-out (electrode extension) settings. These wires require the use of specific gun angles and travel speeds to achieve the best weld quality, too. Training for welding operators without FCAW experience is important.

FILLER METALS AND PROCESSES FOR SHOP APPLICATIONS
For structural steel applications in the shop, FCAW-G wire is common, due to its ease of use and all-position capabilities. These features make it usable by welding operators of varying skill levels. These wires typically have very large parameter windows in which they operate very well, and they are very forgiving to incorrect and or inconsistent technique. FCAW-G wires also can weld on dirtier base metal conditions, such as the mill scale found on hot rolled steel – a common occurrence in structural fabrication. Lastly, these wires are capable of high deposition rates. The extra activities associated with the process, however, can cut into overall productivity. FCAW-G wires produce slag, which must be removed in between passes and after welding. This slag can easily accumulate on the shop floor, equipment and fixtures, leading to additional cleaning.

In some welding applications, MIG welding can be used instead of FCAW-G and can eliminate non-value-added activities in the shop. Since MIG welding doesn’t generate slag, post-weld activities such as grinding or chipping are not necessary, thereby saving labor, time and money. There are some drawbacks to MIG compared to FCAW-G. It is not as easy to use or forgiving to the welding operator, and is more difficult and slower to weld out of position. It is also less capable of welding through mill scale.

Filler metals available for MIG welding include solid wire and metal-cored (or composite) wire. Metal-cored wires address some of the drawbacks listed above. They are more forgiving to welding operator technique, making them easier to use. This feature results from the broad and very fluid weld pool that is common with these wires. Metal-cored wires also operate over a larger range of parameters, making it easier for welding operators to set the power source. Lastly, these wires contain higher levels of deoxidizers (cleaning elements) that allow them to perform better on mill scale or dirty base metal.

The SAW process is used to maximize productivity on structural steel applications in the shop that require long, continuous and possibly multi-pass welds, such as those found on an I-beam. While SAW requires a larger capital expense upfront, it also provides the highest productivity rates. The investment can pay off quickly if a structural application requires a lot of arc-on time. SAW can use solid or metal-cored wires also. The tubular construction of the metal-cored wire results in higher deposition rate at the same amperage as a solid wire, increasing travel speeds to make the same size weld. This, in turn, improves productivity and reduces heat input, which can minimize the need for costly straightening operations.

For example, an 1/8 in diameter SAW solid wire used at 100 wire feed speed (wfs) and 30 volts would result in 650 amps and travel at 22 ipm to get a determined weld size of “X”, whereas a 1/8 in metal-cored wire used at 650 amps would require 150 wfs, 30 volts and must travel at 27.5 ipm to produce the same weld size of “X”. This means that the SAW process with the metal-cored wire increased travel speed 25 percent and reduced heat input 25 percent. For a structural steel welding scenario, that welding productivity gain, along with the heat input reduction that can minimize post-welding activities, can add up to big savings. Since labor is the largest cost in any welding operation, even gaining a small reduction in cycle time can provide huge savings in the long run. This can come from an increase in deposition rate, which would reduce time spent welding, or from reducing/eliminating non-welding activities like grinding, post-weld cleaning, straightening beams, etc.

FINAL THOUGHTS
In any application, quality, productivity and cost savings are critical to operating an efficient and profitable welding operation. The welding of structural steel, whether in the field or in a shop, requires the same care and attention. To gain the best results, fabricators should ask themselves, “Am I using the right process?” If opportunities for improvements exist or problems have occurred, it may be worthwhile to consider a new filler metal and process for the job.

  • Rob wrote:

    Great article. We build this system which had massive gains for our client. https://www.ljwelding.com/blog/case-study-structural-beam-welding-gantry-boosts-deposition-rate-by-up-to-520

  • Alex Yap wrote:

    Great article. Very educational.

    • Akhtarali wrote:

      My name is akhtarali from Pakistan iam tig welding jobs ineed welding work Visa from australia please contact me my what saap number+923469452026

  • Levi Armstrong wrote:

    It’s interesting to know that MIG welding is an excellent choice for structural steel fabrications since it does not generate slag, and you’d save money since post-weld activities are not necessary. My dad plans to contact a structural steel welding service in the city soon for a project he’s doing at home. I’ll share this with him so he’d know the benefits of choosing the MIG welding process. Thanks. http://www.samsweldinginc.com/welding-services-repairs

  • The Weld Report wrote:

    I love the way you write and share your niche! Very interesting and different! Keep it coming! https://theweldreport.com/

  • William Son wrote:

    Such a Nice Article . i would like to share with you guys. Welding Tools

  • sakib wrote:

    I’m really appreciate your work this article is so helpful for the beginners in this field, it’s really helpful for others. https://weldingexpertise.com/

  • Thomas Clarence wrote:

    It was really interesting to read about how stick welding is one of the processes that is most commonly used in the process of constructing things with structural steel. My brother is thinking of doing his career in a trade field and welding is something that is really standing out to him. It seems like it would be a good idea for my brother to research a lot of the different types of welding so that he can know if this is something that he really wants to do. https://acutechworks.com/welding/

  • Jame son wrote:

    Thanks for sharing Very Interesting and Beautiful Article. https://weldingtoolsgeek.com/best-stick-welder/

  • Jack Son wrote:

    In this blog, I evaluate my picks of the top welding boots that I have had the pleasure of testing. I will go through the various pros and cons of each pair of shoes I evaluate, so you won’t have to do the arduous task of sifting through the heaps of confusing information available online.
    https://weldingtoolsgeek.com/best-welding-boots-review/

  • Oliver wrote:

    In previous times, if you needed to do different welding processes, you had to invest in multiple welders, accessories, and consumables. Purchasing all this equipment was a hefty investment even for seasoned welders because the costs quickly add up and become too expensive to the hobbyist welders out there. https://weldingtoolsgeek.com/best-multi-process-welders/

  • Welding wrote:

    Hi buddy! Awesome sharing with full of information I was searching for. Your complete guidance gave me a wonderful end up. Great going.
    Best wishes from: https://weldingmaniac.com/

  • William Son wrote:

    Does the quality of your machine ends-up on causing poor quality during work? This may be due to numerous reasons. Hence, in order to achieve top-quality welding finishing, you must need the right equipment along with some sufficient structural integrity. Thus choosing the right project to adhere to industry codes and standards.
    https://weldingtoolsgeek.com/best-tig-welder-under-500/

  • Sean Pual wrote:

    Although choosing the best TIG welder under 2000 is quite tough as it includes risking your time, energy, and above all your hard-earned money.
    https://weldingtoolsgeek.com/best-tig-welder-under-2000/

  • Daniel Son wrote:

    Today we have highlighted our best multi-process welder under 1000. As for the beginners, one must have a sufficient budget for good quality welding equipment that can be used as an all-purpose during your regular task. Also, we will take few important considerations one must consider before hitting the market as a novice welding buyer.
    https://weldingtoolsgeek.com/best-multi-process-welder-under-1000/

  • David Warner wrote:

    So the welder-generator combos get themselves powered and even welder can use one of the provided energy power to overhead lights, angle grinder, and as a plasma cutter. These power-packed units are especially popular among different people such as auto body repair technicians, farmers, and even DIY enthusiastic. This is due to the flexibility of the usage around any location even you are closer to a power outlet.
    https://weldingtoolsgeek.com/best-multi-process-welder-under-1000/

  • David Warner wrote:

    So the welder-generator combos get themselves powered and even welder can use one of the provided energy power to overhead lights, angle grinder, and as a plasma cutter. These power-packed units are especially popular among different people such as auto body repair technicians, farmers, and even DIY enthusiastic. This is due to the flexibility of the usage around any location even you are closer to a power outlet.
    https://weldingtoolsgeek.com/best-welder-generator-combo/

  • Jame Bond wrote:

    Hence, we have recommended a few suggestions for you. We have highlighted the features of all the best flux core welder under 200. Hence this will help you in picking up the right model for you.
    https://weldingtoolsgeek.com/best-flux-core-welder-under-200/

  • James wrote:

    Sound good. I want to use the same welding model for my home task. I have choose the welding helmet according to my skill.

  • Leon ward wrote:

    Thank you so much for sharing a great article .
    I really appreciate you for sharing a great Welding tips

  • weld spatter wrote:

    great blog!
    I appreciate your article . click here get more information about welding

  • Eoin Morgan wrote:

    hello everyone
    I come across this article and it has great information.
    which is amazing
    thanks for sharing amazing ​article

    cheers
    For more visit
    https://weldingtoolsgeek.com/best-flux-core-welder-under-200/

  • welding pro wrote:

    A great piece of information. You can also find some other good info about welding by visiting
    helmetadviser.com

  • welding tips wrote:

    You have shared great thoughts about steel fabrications. Keeo\p sharing such useful information. Really appreciated.
    welding in budget

End Comment -->
Calendar & Events
Rapid + tct
May 17 - 19, 2022
Detroit, Michigan
Design-2-Part Northern California
May 25 - 26, 2022
Santa Clara, California
Automate
June 6 - 9, 2022
Detroit, Michigan
FABTECH Canada
June 14 - 16, 2022
Toronto, Ontario
IMTS
September 12 - 17, 2022
Chicago, Illinois
FABTECH
November 8 - 10, 2022
Atlanta, Georgia
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement